Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
+2
Bluntokian
Hero
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
I am sure you guys have heard of this but it's so cool that they do it. The only invertebrates to have utilized tools. I would bing it if you want to learn more.
Octopuses have been discovered tip-toeing with coconut-shell halves suctioned to their undersides, then reassembling the halves and disappearing inside for protection or deception, a new study says.
Hero- Site Admin
- Posts : 3231
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-04-04
Location : San Diego, CA
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
Looks like a crab rofl.
Bluntokian- Pacific Sunfish
- Posts : 1315
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-08-29
Age : 30
Location : Charlotte NC
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
i've seen this article on BBC and CBC
~ocean- Moderator
- Posts : 838
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-09-27
Location : Stoon
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
I think it's pretty neat though.
Hero- Site Admin
- Posts : 3231
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-04-04
Location : San Diego, CA
~ocean- Moderator
- Posts : 838
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-09-27
Location : Stoon
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
First invert to utilize tools, makes them super advanced, and with such a short lifespan it is amazing.
Jacobnano- Ornate Boxfish
- Posts : 439
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-09-22
Location : Yakima, WA
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
Well look at how much more advanced we are compared to turtles, And they live insanely long. (not very scientific I know but I wanted to join in )
Bluntokian- Pacific Sunfish
- Posts : 1315
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-08-29
Age : 30
Location : Charlotte NC
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
. Who knows what else Octopi will evolve to become next?
Hero- Site Admin
- Posts : 3231
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-04-04
Location : San Diego, CA
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
I am not certain it is the "first to use tools" it depends on what a "tool" is.
Many inverts collect debris and objects to create dwellings, camouflage, and in general become less obtrusive.
Yes, octopi are VERY smart.. but as for tool usage.. I'm not certain about that one.
Many inverts collect debris and objects to create dwellings, camouflage, and in general become less obtrusive.
Yes, octopi are VERY smart.. but as for tool usage.. I'm not certain about that one.
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
J-P wrote:I am not certain it is the "first to use tools" it depends on what a "tool" is.
Many inverts collect debris and objects to create dwellings, camouflage, and in general become less obtrusive.
Yes, octopi are VERY smart.. but as for tool usage.. I'm not certain about that one.
That's a good point. It also brings up the fact that it is the first documented invertebrate to use tools. It's still a great example of ingenuity.
Hero- Site Admin
- Posts : 3231
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-04-04
Location : San Diego, CA
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
Would a caddisfly nymph building a cocoon out of pond stones and sticks count as using a tool? It carries it with it and uses it as a portable home like a snail would use a shell or we would an RV ... Now watch an octopus complete a maze (and cheat) that is awesome
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
By some definitions I guess it would be considered as using a tool.
Is there actually a video on the maze completing (cheating) octopus?
Is there actually a video on the maze completing (cheating) octopus?
Hero- Site Admin
- Posts : 3231
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-04-04
Location : San Diego, CA
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
there is.. but I couldn't find it in all the junk out there.
There was a maze.. the octo completed it... around the 5th time trial the octo lifted the lid and went straight to the end. It was very good.
There was a maze.. the octo completed it... around the 5th time trial the octo lifted the lid and went straight to the end. It was very good.
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
J-P wrote:I am not certain it is the "first to use tools" it depends on what a "tool" is.
Many inverts collect debris and objects to create dwellings, camouflage, and in general become less obtrusive.
Yes, octopi are VERY smart.. but as for tool usage.. I'm not certain about that one.
A tool is normally something that is used for a purpose, but is not used up while being used. All the uses you listed are equivalent to thing like bricks. Brinks are materials, while the trowel and the wheel barrow are the tools used in handling them.... I think that is how it works, otherwise everything uses tools and we wouldn't have come up with the word!
Michael Milligan- Starry Flounder
- Posts : 306
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2010-07-11
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
Jacobnano wrote:First invert to utilize tools, makes them super advanced, and with such a short lifespan it is amazing.
Short generations is often an asset for a species. Makes for greater adaptability.This is why scientists use fruit flies and bacteria to study evolution, and not turtles
Michael Milligan- Starry Flounder
- Posts : 306
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2010-07-11
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
You should check this video out:
~ocean- Moderator
- Posts : 838
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-09-27
Location : Stoon
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
Hero wrote:Octopuses have been discovered tip-toeing with coconut-shell halves suctioned to their undersides, then reassembling the halves and disappearing inside for protection or deception, a new study says.
Michael Milligan wrote:Jacobnano wrote:First invert to utilize tools, makes them super advanced, and with such a short lifespan it is amazing.
Short generations is often an asset for a species. Makes for greater adaptability.This is why scientists use fruit flies and bacteria to study evolution, and not turtles
But isn't that exactly what hermit crabs do? Without the reassembling part? Or decorator crabs (with the reassembling part)? You do make a good point though about the brick vs. trowel.
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
~ocean wrote:You should check this video out:
Funny video. That mantis shrimp appears to be pretty large.
J-P wrote:
But isn't that exactly what hermit crabs do? Without the reassembling part? Or decorator crabs (with the reassembling part)? You do make a good point though about the brick vs. trowel.
The key part is that the octopus reassembles the halves. I would call it a different case as the shell is an integral part of the hermit crab that it cannot survive without. Octopus are utilizing objects from the environment around them.
Hero- Site Admin
- Posts : 3231
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-04-04
Location : San Diego, CA
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
J-P wrote:Hero wrote:Octopuses have been discovered tip-toeing with coconut-shell halves suctioned to their undersides, then reassembling the halves and disappearing inside for protection or deception, a new study says.Michael Milligan wrote:Jacobnano wrote:First invert to utilize tools, makes them super advanced, and with such a short lifespan it is amazing.
Short generations is often an asset for a species. Makes for greater adaptability.This is why scientists use fruit flies and bacteria to study evolution, and not turtles
But isn't that exactly what hermit crabs do? Without the reassembling part? Or decorator crabs (with the reassembling part)? You do make a good point though about the brick vs. trowel.
If you extend the definition of "tool use" to include hermit crabs, then you would have to say that everything uses tools when they breath or drink and that plants use sunlight as a tool.
Michael Milligan- Starry Flounder
- Posts : 306
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2010-07-11
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
just curious but how would you extend / equate a hermit crab to a plant using the sun?
I don't want to sound argumentative, I'm not. If a plant could pick itself up out of the substrate and move to a more preferable substrate that would be closer to what a hermit crab does. It can pick and choose its home. It is using something it has not produced (unlike a snail), for a specific purpose and intent. BUT, granted there is no 3rd party object involved as in the fish video using the rock to break open a shell. That is true tool use.
If a hermit crab and plant equate, than so does the octopus. Evolution hasn't made it dependent on the object in question (yet), it "uses" it. It uses it to hide. No third party object involved. Thus, no difference IMO. Now if the Octopus used the shell as a shield or to smack the eel attacking it, that would be totally different. Thus I am not certain that the coconut is actually a "tool"
I don't want to sound argumentative, I'm not. If a plant could pick itself up out of the substrate and move to a more preferable substrate that would be closer to what a hermit crab does. It can pick and choose its home. It is using something it has not produced (unlike a snail), for a specific purpose and intent. BUT, granted there is no 3rd party object involved as in the fish video using the rock to break open a shell. That is true tool use.
If a hermit crab and plant equate, than so does the octopus. Evolution hasn't made it dependent on the object in question (yet), it "uses" it. It uses it to hide. No third party object involved. Thus, no difference IMO. Now if the Octopus used the shell as a shield or to smack the eel attacking it, that would be totally different. Thus I am not certain that the coconut is actually a "tool"
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
I am certain the coconut is a tool. It's not part of the octopus' physical anatomy and it is something from its environment it utilized. The hermit crab's shell is an integral part of the hermit crab and isn't really a tool. By that logic, our limbs would be tools.
According to Encyclopedia Britannica, a tool is an instrument for making material changes on other objects, as by cutting, shearing, striking, rubbing, grinding, squeezing, measuring, or other process. By that definition, neither the crab or octopus could be said to use tools.
According to Encyclopedia Britannica, a tool is an instrument for making material changes on other objects, as by cutting, shearing, striking, rubbing, grinding, squeezing, measuring, or other process. By that definition, neither the crab or octopus could be said to use tools.
Hero- Site Admin
- Posts : 3231
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2009-04-04
Location : San Diego, CA
Re: Octopus Utilizes Coconuts
J-P wrote:just curious but how would you extend / equate a hermit crab to a plant using the sun?
I wouldn't. I was saying that any definition of tool use that included the hermit crab would as a consequence include plants. The crab uses shells as a basic requirement, as the plant uses the sun. It's not optional and every member of the species uses the same thing in exactly the same way. I don't imagine a lot of forethought on the crabs part, he just backs his ass into it. He doesn't need, nor does he have, a purpose in mind, merely the instinct to perform an action. When a chimp or a crow fashion a tool to pick out bugs, they are doing so with the future in mind, and in intended result. And a tool is a means to an end, not the end itself. Using something does not make it a tool, using it with forethought and intention and for an end apart from using the tool, makes it a tool. Hitting things does not a hammer make. Using a hammer to make things via hitting does.
Michael Milligan- Starry Flounder
- Posts : 306
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2010-07-11
Similar topics
» Octopus for my Aquarium
» Anyone ready for an octopus?
» My haul from night collecting last night: Pipe fish, Octopus, Tubesnouts......
» Pretty sure its a Giant Pacific Octopus (E. Dofleini) yup, pretty sure.
» Anyone ready for an octopus?
» My haul from night collecting last night: Pipe fish, Octopus, Tubesnouts......
» Pretty sure its a Giant Pacific Octopus (E. Dofleini) yup, pretty sure.
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|